S.E.R.G. WP Series #08-2026: "Five Vehicle-to-Grid (V2G) Programs Compared: Business Models, Policy, and Allocation of Benefits"
Consumer-oriented vehicle-to-grid (V2G) services are moving from pilot projects to commercial deployment, yet their success depends on how business models allocate costs and revenues between electric vehicle (EV) owners and aggregators. This paper evaluates five commercial V2G offers in France, Germany, the Netherlands, and the United Kingdom by combining an incentivecompatibility framework with simulations of 200 EVs over January–June 2025. We compare EV-owner electricity bills, aggregator profits, and two policy scenarios: net metering and retailer–aggregator separation. The results show that V2G can substantially reduce EV-owner bills, but only when business models either limit fees for battery discharging, make V2G cycles less frequent, or compensate consumers for its associated costs. If high arbitrage margins are required (trading only when the gap from low to high price is large), average EV-owner bills fall by 50% compared to an unmanaged-charging baseline. In contrast, low-margin arbittrage can increase charging volumes, thus taxes and network charges, leading to higher EV-owner bills despite greater aggregator profits. Regarding policy choices, we find that net metering can unlock the potential of V2G for intertemporal energy storage by reducing the market price spreads required for profitable arbitrage, while retailer-aggregator separation can improve consumer outcomes when dispatch decisions internalize retail revenues. These findings highlight the importance of designing V2G policies jointly with commercial contracts, as the value delivered to consumers depends not only on energy market revenues but also on how the costs and benefits of battery cycling are allocated.
