Sustainable Economy Research Group (S.E.R.G.)
CentraleSupélec / Paris-Saclay University

S.E.R.G. WP Series #05-2026: "Implications of design choices in the allocation of Carbon Contracts for Difference – a review of the literature"

Energy

2026 · Katharina Menke, Albert Banal-Estanol, Olivier Massol

Carbon Contracts for Difference (CCfDs) have emerged as a key economic policy instrument for industrial decarbonization in Europe and increasingly worldwide. They are contractual agreements between governments and developers of low-carbon projects that guarantee a fixed carbon price over the duration of the contract, serving both as a hedge and a subsidy. A key aspect of implementing CCfDs is the design of their allocation, which significantly impacts both the achievement of policy objectives and the associated costs. While several studies touch upon aspects of CCfD allocation, most existing literature addresses these topics only briefly or focuses on individual elements in isolation. Our work contributes to this emerging field by integrating the existing literature into a comprehensive analysis of CCfD allocation design and its associated implications. We present a structured review that categorizes key allocation design aspects according to predefined policy evaluation criteria (effectiveness, static efficiency, dynamic efficiency, and practical and legal feasibility) and practical design considerations. Our analysis highlights important trade-offs, such as those between static and dynamic efficiency, and identifies synergies in allocation design. Additionally, it draws attention to topics not yet explored in depth in the literature, including pricing methods in auctions, penalties and bidding strategies, and the interplay between allocation design options and broader CCfD design.

Key Points: WPS 2026 - 5 Menken NTS.pdf

© 2026 Sustainable Economy Research Group (SERG) at CentraleSupélec / Paris-Saclay University / Industrial Engineering Department (LGI). All rights reserved.